Defending the Guilty: Truth and Lies in the Criminal Courtroom
Alex McBride
Defending the Guilty: Truth and Lies in the Criminal Courtroom
“As a criminal barrister, you work with the material you get: a junkie shoplifter with thirty-five previous convictions and four packs of Lidl’s frozen chicken stuffed down his trousers is heading only one way…” Every day, like every criminal barrister in this country, Alex McBride stands up in court and attempts to save people from criminal conviction, prison, even a lifetime behind bars. Sometimes he's had only a few hours to prepare his case. Sometimes his client is obviously guilty. In this memoir, he takes us behind the scenes of Britain's criminal justice system - in barristers’ chambers, in the courtroom, in the cells and on the streets - introducing us to its outlandish personalities, arcane eccentricities and its many moving stories of triumph and defeat. Whether he's defending hapless teenagers at Harlow Youth Court or prosecuting gold bullion robbers at the Bailey, his hair-raising tales reveal the secrets of courtroom success and what it takes to survive in this chaotic world of fluked escapes and crushed hopes. Throughout he attempts to answer that most important question: how do we ensure that the guilty are convicted and the innocent walk free?
3.5 out of 5 based on 3 reviews
|
Omniscore:
|
| Classification |
Non-fiction |
| Genre |
True Crime, Business, Finance & Law |
| Format |
Paperback |
| Pages |
288 |
| RRP |
£12.99 |
| Date of Publication |
April 2010 |
| ISBN |
978-0670918300 |
| Publisher |
Viking |
| |
“As a criminal barrister, you work with the material you get: a junkie shoplifter with thirty-five previous convictions and four packs of Lidl’s frozen chicken stuffed down his trousers is heading only one way…” Every day, like every criminal barrister in this country, Alex McBride stands up in court and attempts to save people from criminal conviction, prison, even a lifetime behind bars. Sometimes he's had only a few hours to prepare his case. Sometimes his client is obviously guilty. In this memoir, he takes us behind the scenes of Britain's criminal justice system - in barristers’ chambers, in the courtroom, in the cells and on the streets - introducing us to its outlandish personalities, arcane eccentricities and its many moving stories of triumph and defeat. Whether he's defending hapless teenagers at Harlow Youth Court or prosecuting gold bullion robbers at the Bailey, his hair-raising tales reveal the secrets of courtroom success and what it takes to survive in this chaotic world of fluked escapes and crushed hopes. Throughout he attempts to answer that most important question: how do we ensure that the guilty are convicted and the innocent walk free?
Reviews
The Daily Mail
Marcus Berkmann
"He details his own cock-ups and disasters with the typical relish of the born humorous writer, but every case he describes has a point to make. He also throws in some historical background, all elegantly written with admirable conciseness. What gradually builds up is a fascinating overview of our criminal justice system... This is both a rigorous and a scrupulously fair book, as well as a very funny one."
13/04/2010
Read Full Review
The Literary Review
Harry Mount
"The real life of criminal barristers – sometimes thrilling, often tawdry and dull; sometimes lucrative, often terribly paid – is expertly caught in this book… his conclusion is convincing: for all the horrors of this distinctly unglamorous, rackety life, it’s a pretty good thing that privileged, educated figures still speak on behalf of people who have nothing."
01/04/2010
Read Full Review
The Observer
Gudrun Young
"While there is a clear appetite for legal dramas among the public and an obvious human interest value in what we do, does anyone really want to know the abstruse mechanics of how a courtroom works or have explained to them the irritating "lingo" used by barristers? It doesn't help that McBride's humour is so puerile. Passages such as: "At the end of a trial, you want to look the prosecutor in the eyes and say, 'You thought you had a stone bonker of a case, did you, pal? Well I shoved it up your arse, cocksucker,'" are no substitute for real wit... Ultimately, the book possesses neither the flourish of the true raconteur nor the vigour of proper intellectual endeavour."
11/04/2010
Read Full Review